The first concern of true
humanitarian intervention would be the safety and well-being of
people, the protection of human life. True a humanitarian
intervention would attempt to bring justice, peace, co-operation
and understanding to people. It would offer neutral mediation.
It would work in the spirit of true concern for all the people
involved of in a conflict. It would aim to prevent violence,
stop the flow of arms, arrest those believed to be perpetrating
violence.
It would bring suspects to trial
in a genuinely neutral criminal court. It would bring medical
and economic assistance and offer help with psychological
counselling and reconstruction work.
It might develop peace plans and
administrative structures in discussion with the people
concerned in a conflict, encouraging these people to develop
their own solutions rather than impose a solution worked out by
faraway experts.
Humanitarian intervention should
only be started if there is a reasonable chance of improving the
situation.
The independence and integrity of
peace keeping forces
A humanitarian peacekeeping force
would need to be under the control of a body like the United
Nations, and totally separate from the control of one or more
powerful nations. (There should not be any significant forces
outside UN control.) Such a force would ensure that it would be
protective of human life, conducive to reducing conflict,
environmentally benign, use minimum force and operate in
compliance with international law. The peace keeping force would
have to be neutral and attempt to stop violence on both or all
sides in a dispute. The arresting of criminals and the
prevention of the flow of arms to killers would be part of the
work of a peace keeping force.
Non-exploitive intervention
Peace-keeping should not be
undertaken for the benefit of militarists and arms
manufacturers, nor for the benefit of big business or
new-world-order imperialists. To express the obvious, peace
keeping is in the interest of the entire world because peace
developed anywhere in the world helps to make the world safer.
In carrying out humanitarian
intervention civilian experts and non-governmental organisations
may have much to offer and be more appropriate and more
cost-effective agencies than the ministers and military of
concerned countries.
The media
In recent conflicts it has
sometimes been the case that one side has employed a
particularly energetic public relations team to present horror
stories about the actions of their enemy to the media and to
minimise accounts of their own violence or to blame it on the
behaviour of their enemy. Sometimes, they have stooped to the
depths of cynicism and criminality by carrying out atrocities
against their own people and laying the blame on their enemies.
Too often the media have shown
themselves willing to accept, at face value, accounts of events
provided by the public relations departments of belligerents.
Many news organisations need to
place integrity and accuracy in their reporting above the need
for a good story or the easy use of ready-made accounts and
unchecked statistics. The emotive language of press handouts
should be considered critically not simply used verbatim.
A certain amount of self-reform
urgently needs to take place. The media should view information
provided to them in war situations with mature scepticism, be
concerned to tell the truth, and carry out their own independent
research into stories provided to them. They should be
sufficiently self-aware to avoid a constant stream of racially
biassed information. If the media do not do a better job the
risk for them is that readers and viewers will desert them and
go to more truthful sources of information. Western media told a
different story from the rest of the world and the intellectual
weakness of western media has been widely noted. (39)
Failure all round
NATO’s intervention in Kosovo,
the bombing of Yugoslavia, the international criminal tribunal
which sits in the Hague, and the conduct of the media during the
last decade of war in Yugoslavia fail on all the basic
requirements set out above.